Paul Hindmarsh – a very well respected producer and commentator on brass bands
I met Malcolm Arnold twice. On the second occasion he was frail and taciturn, a shadow of his former self. Decades of ill health, mental and physical, had taken their toll. The first time was very different. It was over half a century ago when I was a music undergraduate at Birmingham University. He came to talk to us about his music. What he said I do not recall. My lasting impression was of a jovial character, rather flushed and overweight, who asked us afterwards where the nearest pub was. That’s students for you! That was the outgoing Arnold, composer of award-winning film music, bracing overture and some brilliant symphonies. His music, like Mahler’s, embraced a world of emotions – the irreverent humour, tender sentiment, deep emotion, joy and despair, with a penchant for high drama and colour. I had no idea then but have learned since the 60s and early 70s was peak brass band time for Arnold. That side of his personality shines through each of the pieces.
They form the spine of this fabulous celebration of Arnold band classics from Foden’s Band and their musical director Michael Fowles. The Malcolm Arnold Society, whose idea this album is, are to be congratulated for complementing his well much-loved brass band originals with a selection of less familiar orchestral works sympathetically reimagined on the band. The booklet design is strikingly colourful. The notes by Arnold authority Piers Burton-Page provide comprehensive background, context and musical commentary – a proper job, as Arnold would have heard countless time during his Cornwall years.
So to the music. Foden’s and Fowles approach the first two Little Suites with serious intent but a delightful lightness of touch. Nothing is over-played, but the range of character leaps off the page with razor-sharp detail, rhythmic definition and engaging colour. The Siciliano (Suite No. 1) and Cavatina (Suite No. 2) are beautifully shaped and expressed, but not over sentimentalised.
Of the two big pieces, Fantasy (1973) has been a regular on the contest stage and recording studio for 50 years. I’m afraid it is not my favourite Arnold. It all seems rather underdeveloped and short-winded. You can hear that Arnold was constrained by the 10-minute time limit imposed on him by the organisers of the National Championships. Having said that, Foden’s makes a really convincing case for it because of the sheer quality of the playing – the dynamic range, the deft details in the Dance and Scherzo and the heart-on-sleeve emotions in the central Elegy, which for me is the work’s saving grace!
Song of Freedom (1972) is receiving its CD premiere. Recorded in the warm acoustic of Manchester’s Stoller Hall, Foden’s is joined by the choir of Chetham’s School of Music. The musicianship of these talented young specialist students shines through. Their sound is surprisingly mature in places given that the work was commissioned by the National Schools Brass Band Association, for performance by the average School choir and band. The texts were selected by Arnold from submissions by school aged children on themes of freedom. The results are strikingly direct, touching issues that are as relevant in the 21st century as they were in 1972. Arnold was impressed by the sadness of some of them. He responded appropriately in a haunting Elegy. The other movements, Prelude, Hymn and Postlude are uneven in quality, but Arnold is at pains to make the text audible. The choir’s diction is exemplary.
It is refreshing to hear some ‘new’ transcriptions. In 2002 life-long Arnold enthusiast Neil Richmond (a retired music teacher and co-founder of Harrogate Town Band) scored the fresh and invigorating overture to the film The Roots of Heaven (1958). This could be a real winner – five minutes encompassing so many Arnold musical fingerprints. The March Overseas (1960), also transcribed most effectively by Neil Richmond, sounds as though Arnold still had Alford’s Colonel Bogey on his mind after incorporating it in his music for Bridge on the Kwai (1957). It’s none the worse for that – a spirited alternative to Padstow Lifeboat perhaps. From the same vintage, Phillip Littlemore’s 2006 suite from the ballet music to Sweeney Todd (1959) is notable for its juxtaposition of the eerily sinister with Edwardian charm and slapstick comic capers – a delight.
Philip Sparke’s burnished 1986 transcription of Fanfare for a Festival opens the celebration is colourful fashion. The final track is, for me, the album’s highlight. Andrew Duncan’s superb reimagining of the Peterloo Overture (1967) is an object lesson in the transcriber’s craft – knowing what to omit, what to retain and what to highlight. Foden’s performance and Michael Fowles’ reading had me on the edge of my chair. They convey the undercurrent of danger and threat with such intensity. The visceral energy and violence that Arnold captures so vividly is matched in the power and drama of the playing. The triumphant final theme, with all its ‘bells and whistles’, brings the album to a fitting conclusion.
The recording is balanced up close, so every detail can be heard. What a good job they are all in the right place. I enjoyed this a lot, as you can probably tell!
PAUL HINDMARSH
The CD can be purchased here
You must be logged in to post a comment.